Rethinking School Holidays: A Closer Look at the Pros and Cons

Rethinking School Holidays A Closer Look at the Pros and Cons cover image
By Adam Gillett*

The perennial debate over the length of school holidays in the UK has recently sparked discussions about transitioning from the traditional 6-week summer break to a shorter 4-week period. A soon to be released report by the Nuffield Foundation will suggest that school holidays should be changed to support wellbeing, behaviour and also avoid socio-economically deprived students from falling behind.

Advocates argue that such a change could positively impact staff and student wellbeing, while opponents raise concerns about historical structures, parent holidays, and childcare. 

On the positive side, proponents suggest that shorter summer breaks might alleviate the stress associated with returning to school, creating a smoother transition for both staff and students. Additionally, aligning school holidays with parent annual leave could simplify family travel plans. These changes might appear promising, offering solutions to contemporary challenges.

However, the issues surrounding school holidays extend far beyond their duration. The recruitment and retention crisis in education is intricately linked to concerns such as workload, student and parent conduct towards staff, and an overall feeling of undervaluation in society.

Teachers often grapple with excessive workloads, impacting their job satisfaction and contributing to the recruitment and retention crisis. Addressing workload concerns and providing adequate support can have a more significant impact on teacher satisfaction than altering holiday lengths.

Instances of disrespectful behaviour from students and parents toward staff contribute to job dissatisfaction. Promoting a culture of respect and appreciation for educators can create a more positive working environment. A clear government charter on parental communication with schools could revolutionise the wellbeing of staff members, especially heads of year, associate staff and SLT. 

A pervasive sentiment of undervaluation in society affects teachers’ morale and job satisfaction. Recognising and appreciating the vital role educators play in shaping the future can lead to a more fulfilling professional experience. For a start, the year on year wrangling over pay needs to stop, with teachers pay reflecting the ever increasing role we are expected to play. Teachers often fulfil the role of parent, social worker, police officer, healthcare professional and many positions in between. 

In conclusion, while altering the structure of school holidays may have some merits, the underlying issues in education, such as workload, conduct, and perceived undervaluation, demand more comprehensive solutions. Rather than focusing solely on holiday adjustments, efforts should be directed towards addressing these fundamental challenges to create a more sustainable and fulfilling educational environments for all stakeholders. Ultimately, it’s the quality, not the quantity, of time that makes the most significant impact.

*Disclaimer: Adam Gillett contributed to this blog post in his personal capacity. The views and opinions expressed are his own and do not necessarily represent the view or position of Minds Ahead.
Picture of Author: Adam Gillett
Author: Adam Gillett

Associate Vice Principal
Penistone Grammar School
Learning and Development Specialist at Minds Ahead

Other blog posts

       Share this on social media: