fbpix

Are schools contributing to the rise in children’s mental health difficulties?

Are schools contributing to the rise in children's mental health difficulties?

This post is based on the UK Government’s Independent Review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism.

An independent national review highlights the social, cultural and environmental pressures affecting young people’s mental health. What does the evidence tell us about school culture, belonging and the conditions children need to thrive?

Why are more children and young people experiencing mental health difficulties?

It is a question increasingly asked by schools, families, policymakers and mental health professionals. And one that often leads to discussions about resilience, social media, diagnosis and access to mental health services.

The Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism, published in October 2026, examines the evidence behind increasing mental health difficulties and rising demand for support. Its findings are significant.

The review identifies a genuine increase in common mental health difficulties, particularly among children and young people. However, it also makes clear that no single explanation accounts for this increase.

Instead, it points towards interacting social, cultural, environmental and systemic pressures that are changing how people live, develop and experience the world.

For schools, this raises an important question: are we doing enough to address the conditions that influence children’s mental health, rather than concentrating predominantly on supporting individuals once difficulties have developed?

More insecurity, more comparison and less belonging

The review identifies four broad changes shaping mental health and wellbeing.

1. Uncertainty and insecurity

Poverty, financial pressures, housing instability and wider uncertainty contribute to psychological distress.

Children experience these pressures through their families, communities and everyday lives. Financial insecurity can affect access to activities, opportunities for social participation and the stability of home environments.

These influences do not affect all pupils equally: young people experiencing poverty, discrimination, social exclusion or other disadvantages may face multiple, interacting risks.

For schools, this reinforces the importance of recognising that mental health cannot be understood solely through individual characteristics or behaviours.

As we all know, a child’s difficulties with concentration, relationships or emotional regulation may be influenced by circumstances extending well beyond the classroom.

2. More evaluation and comparison

The review suggests that contemporary life has become increasingly evaluative, with more opportunities for comparison and scrutiny of performance, appearance and social standing.

Educational pressures form part of this picture. The review finds that education has become a more significant contributor to distress than for previous generations, although it does not identify education as the principal cause of the overall increase.

This is an important distinction. High expectations and academic ambition are not inherently harmful. However, the ways in which expectations are communicated and experienced can influence pupils’ wellbeing.

School leaders might therefore consider whether their approaches to assessment, behaviour, achievement and recognition create unnecessary pressures or reinforce feelings of inadequacy.

Social media can intensify comparison and exposure to negative experiences, including bullying, but the review cautions against treating it as a single explanation for rising mental health difficulties.

3. Belonging and loneliness

One of the review’s particularly important findings concerns the decline in opportunities for connection and belonging.

Reduced youth and community provision, loneliness and social isolation have weakened some of the protective environments in which young people develop relationships, confidence and a sense of identity.

For schools, this should be a significant concern. Belonging is not simply a desirable aspect of school life. It is associated with mental health, participation, engagement and educational outcomes.

We have previously explored this in our Minds Ahead article, Mental health in schools: Belonging is essential for well-being.

Drawing on research from UCL’s Institute of Education, that article highlighted the importance of inclusive school cultures, positive relationships between staff and pupils, and approaches to behaviour that strengthen rather than undermine participation and connection.

More recent research adds weight to this understanding. A 2022 systematic review of school connectedness and mental health, examining longitudinal and intervention studies, identified school connectedness as a potentially important protective factor for depression and anxiety, while also highlighting limitations in the evidence for particular interventions.

Similarly, a 2025 meta-analysis involving more than 57,000 adolescents found a reciprocal relationship: stronger school connectedness predicted slightly lower subsequent depressive symptoms, while depressive symptoms also predicted reduced subsequent connectedness.

In other words, belonging and mental health can influence one another.

This matters because improving mental health is not solely a question of identifying individual difficulties. It also involves examining whether pupils feel accepted, connected and valued within their school communities. A school may offer numerous mental health interventions while simultaneously maintaining practices or environments that leave some pupils feeling excluded or disconnected.

The critical question is not simply whether belonging is included within a school’s wellbeing strategy, but whether it is experienced in everyday school life.

4. Rest and recovery

The review also identifies reduced opportunities for play, physical activity, time outdoors and uninterrupted sleep. Increasingly structured routines and digitally connected lives can limit opportunities for rest, recovery and meaningful social interaction. These experiences are particularly important during childhood and adolescence.

Schools cannot control every aspect of children’s lives, but they can consider how the school day, curriculum, extracurricular activities and physical environment contribute to healthy development. This includes opportunities for play, movement, creativity, connection and recovery from academic or social pressures.

Again, the emphasis shifts from asking children simply to manage pressure more effectively towards examining whether those pressures can be reduced or better balanced.

Why a holistic approach to school mental health matters

Our holistic approach to school mental health starts from the understanding that mental health is shaped by interacting biological, psychological, social and environmental factors.

Rather than viewing mental health primarily as an individual problem requiring a reactive intervention, we encourage schools to consider the wider circumstances in which children learn, develop and participate.

Our approach involves five interconnected elements:

  1. Think holistically – consider the whole child. Understand pupils within the context of their individual needs, identities, relationships, family circumstances and wider experiences.
  2. Plan strategically – consider the whole school. Develop a coherent approach that connects school culture, curriculum, leadership, policies and provision.
  3. Take preventive measures – look at the whole picture. Examine how everyday school experiences can protect mental health or contribute to difficulties.
  4. Be proactive – join up with the whole system. Recognise needs early and work effectively with families, health professionals and community services.
  5. Be reflective – bring your whole self. Critically examine assumptions, evaluate the impact of practice and adapt approaches in response to evidence and experience.

These principles are particularly relevant to the wider determinants highlighted in the independent review. They recognise that mental health is influenced not only by what happens to a child, but also by the environments, relationships and systems surrounding them.

Importantly, a holistic approach is not about transferring responsibility for wider social problems onto schools. Schools cannot resolve poverty, housing insecurity or reductions in community provision independently. However, they can examine how their own environments interact with these challenges, strengthen protective factors and ensure that support is coordinated with the wider system.

School culture: a protective factor or an additional pressure?

If children’s mental health is influenced by their environments, schools need to consider the mental health implications of everyday policies and practices.

This extends beyond dedicated wellbeing programmes.

For example:

  • Behaviour and inclusion: Do responses to behaviour help pupils reconnect with learning and relationships, or might they reinforce exclusion and disengagement?
  • Assessment and achievement: How are academic expectations balanced with encouragement, psychological safety and recognition of individual progress?
  • Relationships and belonging: Do all pupils experience meaningful connections with peers and trusted adults?
  • SEND and neurodivergence: Are environments adapted to individual needs, or are pupils repeatedly expected to accommodate inflexible systems?
  • School culture: Are staff supported to model positive relationships, emotional regulation and healthy approaches to challenge?

These questions are particularly important for pupils who experience additional vulnerabilities. Responding effectively requires more than recognising an individual’s needs. It also requires examining and addressing the barriers within the environment.

This is consistent with the graduated approach outlined in the SEND Code of Practice, which requires schools to identify needs, plan appropriate provision and review its impact. Meanwhile, Keeping Children Safe in Education (2026) reinforces the responsibility of schools to recognise concerns and work within a wider system of support and safeguarding.

These frameworks support a broader understanding of school responsibilities, although neither should be interpreted as requiring schools to become clinical mental health services.

Beyond resilience: changing the conditions as well as supporting the individual

One implication of the review is that we need to be careful about placing too much emphasis on individual resilience.

Helping children develop emotional understanding, coping skills and confidence remains important. But there are limits to what individual skills can achieve when someone is exposed to persistent stress, exclusion, insecurity or harmful environments.

If a pupil experiences ongoing bullying, is the solution primarily to strengthen their resilience, or to address the conditions allowing the bullying to continue?

If a young person feels disconnected from school, should we focus solely on improving their emotional coping skills, or also examine relationships, inclusion and opportunities for meaningful participation?

In practice, both individual support and environmental change may be needed. However, it is often easier to encourage a child to attend a mindfulness club than to confront the underlying cultural, organisational or systemic factors contributing to their distress.

The former places the emphasis on helping the child cope with their environment; the latter asks whether the environment itself needs to change.

For schools, it means looking beyond the number of interventions offered and considering the impact of their everyday culture and practices.

Reacting to difficulties or creating healthier environments?

The review’s findings should prompt reflection across the education sector. It is increasingly clear that mental health cannot be improved solely by expanding access to individual support after difficulties have emerged.

Prevention also matters. This requires schools to consider how their culture, relationships, policies, curriculum and physical environments influence wellbeing, alongside ensuring appropriate targeted and specialist provision when needed.

The challenge for schools is therefore not simply to ask how they can provide more mental health support, or identify need earlier. It is to ask a more fundamental question:

What would a genuinely mentally healthy school look like – and how might our existing practices, structures and expectations help or hinder us in creating one?

References and further reading